5 STAR MOTOR GROUP INC.
Used Car Dealers in Rochester, NY
We are dedicated to providing the ultimate automobile buying experience. Our dealership is your #1 source for buying a quality pre-owned vehicles. We have extensive relationships in the dealer community allowing us to purchase a wide variety of lease returns and new car trades at exceptional values. This enables us to pass along huge savings on the highest quality vehicles of your choice. In addition, we offer a full array of financing options to meet your needs.
If you need help with any aspect of the buying process, please don’t hesitate to contact us.
Handy picked
Featured Listings
2018 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited Sahara (JK) Sport Utility 4D
$21,000
2018
68,848 miles
Automatic
Gasoline
Find by body type
Popular Makes
Nissan
2 Listings
Ford
2 Listings
Honda
1 Listings
VOLKSWAGEN
0 Listings
Why choose us?
Wide range of brands
We can help with your financing plan, we can offer some tips and tricks. Drive off with this dream car of yours regardless of your credit history.
Trusted by our clients
We can help with your financing plan, we can offer some tips and tricks. Drive off with this dream car of yours regardless of your credit history.
Fast & easy financing
We can help with your financing plan, we can offer some tips and tricks. Drive off with this dream car of yours regardless of your credit history.
Testimonials
Sam Pata (Im_wambam)
17:39 30 Jan 26
I can't thank Markos And Chase enough. I went in there for exactly what i wanted and got it!
Process was very smooth, and easy! Very clean and OUTSTANDING communication. I couldn't have had a better experience. Will be recommending more to purchase cars from them!
Thank you again! will upload pictures soon as well!
3 week update! so far so good! will upload the pictures when I get some time.
10-month update, have had 0 issues with the car. Car is still running great!
Company was sold, Car is now having issue's, I am unable to get information on my warranty...
Process was very smooth, and easy! Very clean and OUTSTANDING communication. I couldn't have had a better experience. Will be recommending more to purchase cars from them!
Thank you again! will upload pictures soon as well!
3 week update! so far so good! will upload the pictures when I get some time.
10-month update, have had 0 issues with the car. Car is still running great!
Company was sold, Car is now having issue's, I am unable to get information on my warranty...
Bruce Schaefer
23:05 22 Jan 26
We went in to buy my granddaughter a car.
She found one she liked and we sat down to make a deal. It was a no dicker sticker. They seemed very nice and accommodating. We noticed a small rust spot on the back quarter panel. We said that needed to be sanded and painted. They agreed.
The first time she brought the car in they said the didn't have the right shade of paint. The next time they fixed it by putting what looks like Bondo over the rust spot and didn't even bother to sand it.
I wouldn't deal with them again.
I would spend a few hundred dollars more at a reputable dealer.
She found one she liked and we sat down to make a deal. It was a no dicker sticker. They seemed very nice and accommodating. We noticed a small rust spot on the back quarter panel. We said that needed to be sanded and painted. They agreed.
The first time she brought the car in they said the didn't have the right shade of paint. The next time they fixed it by putting what looks like Bondo over the rust spot and didn't even bother to sand it.
I wouldn't deal with them again.
I would spend a few hundred dollars more at a reputable dealer.
PrintSide Products
16:07 01 Dec 25
I purchased a Car for our Daughter 6/19/2024 after a few days we noticed issues and asked if we could trade for a car with added cash so they would gain not lose and was rudely told no! Fast forward with hardly any driving but to and from her school which is 1 mile away, the transmission had to be replaced ( I think they knew this when they sold it to us) The car had a smokey smell when purchased they said would go away in a few days after they detailed it!! The smell took 6 months to subside and when i called them they basically let me know its nothing I or they could do about it! I purchased a worthless aftermarket warranty (Prime protect) as many repair shops won't let parts be sent in, and they are know for being difficult... The car seems to be a lemon from the start after almost $11k cash not finance I am now looking to get her another car as things keep breaking. I would caution anyone dealing with this Dealership to go somewhere else as this was an awful buying experience and myself, friends, and family will never be returning to this place in Rochester, ny to purchase not even an air fresher!!!!!!!! STAY AWAY!!!!!!
Andrew Liu
18:07 07 Sep 25
Loved Malcolm and some of the used car options he gave us. Got to do a test drive and loved how clean the place was inside. Unfortunately, we were stuck on a certain budget and were not able to move forward with the type of car we wanted. Him and his partner just started at this location recently and I forsee great things in their business.
Simeon Sinclair
17:28 04 Sep 25
I got to meet the owners who were very friendly and they had a wealthy of knowledge and were very willing to give me updates and information about the process of my new car and were willing to work around my schedule they made the process very easy and exciting
Laura Conover
02:52 13 Aug 25
Awesome team. Talked to each individual working behind the counter and constantly made the transaction smooth and straight forward. Definitely recommend them
Unfortunately I need to edit this. After receiving my car I found out I had issues. And no one did right by me to fix it and ignored my calls and mags to find out the company was having issues and sold it to a new manager. The old management wrote incorrect statements about the issue which caused the place to not fix my issues. I was lied to about receiving help due to the incorrect statements on my file. Til this day still having issues
Unfortunately I need to edit this. After receiving my car I found out I had issues. And no one did right by me to fix it and ignored my calls and mags to find out the company was having issues and sold it to a new manager. The old management wrote incorrect statements about the issue which caused the place to not fix my issues. I was lied to about receiving help due to the incorrect statements on my file. Til this day still having issues
Tyler Brado
23:36 13 Jul 25
Their professionalism and speed had me driving my new car off their lot in a matter of days. That's only because I couldn't make the drive the day after I contacted them about buying. The car is in excellent condition, freshly detailed, and had a full tank when I left. As embarrassing as this is, I accidentally paid John $500 more than the agreed price because of the deposit I placed prior to buying. This man reached out to let me know and sent a check in the mail the next day. Customer service A+++++. They definitely let everyone see the Lambo though haha.
Gard Ferrentino
04:05 27 Jul 24
Upon walking into this random dealer I found on Google, I was pleasantly surprised. The dealership was pristine and very clean with a wide variety of cars to choose from. All were detailed and fronted. Approaching John and Markos, they were confident and incredibly easy and welcoming to work with. They let us experience the cars in interest with no pressure and let us test drive any vehicle on the lot. Unlike most dealers, John and Markos were negotiable, throwing in add-ons to make sure we were getting a quality and worthy purchase. I will absolutely do the hour and a half drive again to secure another car from them because it's nothing like I've experienced before from a dealer.
Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter and stay updated with our offer
We are dedicated to provide you with the ultimate automobile buying experience. Our dealership is your #1 source for buying a quality pre-owned vehicle.
Business Hours
Mon – Thu: 10am – 7pm
Fri: 10am – 5pm
Sat: 10am – 3pm
Sun: Appointment Only
Copyright © 2026. All rights reserved. 5 Star Motor Group Inc
Produced by RocOn Marketing